This page is http://www.stewartfarm.org/phragmites/Bobsnotes.php
This site hosted by StewartFarm.org, 2007 Stewart Road, Harsens Island, Michigan 48028.
Note: We do not consider reading the handouts a substitute for attending a workshop where you can see and hear all of the details of this subject. In addition, being able to clarify any questions you have about the materials provided can be very important in making sure the work is done properly and that the results will be rewarding. We intend to conduct future workshops to meet the demand. Please let us know if you are interested. There is no charge for these workshops. Sincerely, Bob and Chuck
Persistent Phragmites sprouting up through new pavement
By Bob Williams, Bob@StewartFarm.org , 8-12-08
Why control Phragmites?
Problems caused by Phragmites include:
limits access for recreation
clogs water intakes
fills in canals, rivers and streams and reduces water flow capacity
dries out wetland areas
reduces native plant population and plant diversity
reduces animal population and diversity
reduced property values
How does it spread?
It spreads mostly by rhizomes rather than seed. Controlling Phragmites requires killing the existing root system.
Cutting and/or burning Phragmites - Does that work to control it?
Not well. In general, there is little change to the health of a stand of Phragmites due to cutting or burning. In some cases it may actually encourage growth. Small standalone patches may be controlled by constant cutting over a period of many years. If the stand being cut is adjacent to an uncut stand, the area being cut will continue to grow by getting its energy from the adjacent root system.
Should I try pulling it out?
No. That will break the roots into many pieces, each of which will grow into more Phragmites.
What can control Phragmites?
The only known method of control is a multi-year treatment with herbicide. The best control is achieved when herbicide is used as part of a long term plan which includes cutting and/or burning. The cutting or burning helps reduce the dead stands of material so the chemicals can reach this year's green leaves and stems. However, don't cut or burn within the four weeks prior to herbicide treatment. Burning as opposed to cutting has the additional benefit of exposing the soil to encourage competing plant germination from the seed bank in the soil.
Before you begin to control your Phragmites
Make sure you know that what you are treating is actually Phragmites.
Also, there are some native varieties of Phragmites which should be protected.
It is our understanding that no native species of phragmites have been found in South East Michigan recently. If you find out otherwise please let us know.
For Identification help see http://www.Phragmites.info
What herbicides can we use to control Phragmites?
In Michigan, if you want to kill phragmites on dry land above the ordinary high water mark, on your own property, with chemicals you can buy at any garden store, you can use RoundUp or a similar Glyphosate based product. Spray it on the leaves and stems sometime from mid-August through the end of September. Follow all instructions on the label.
There are other herbicides, such as Imazapyr (Habitat), which can be sprayed on Phragmites earlier in the summer and may have a slightly better control rate; however, these products are usually too expensive for the average homeowner. Government agencies are the primary users of these expensive products for Phragmites control.
If you spray plants which are in the water or growing from ground which is below the "ordinary high water mark" (OHWM), you may need a permit from the MDEQ. See our other web page on the subject of permits at http://www.stewartfarm.org/phragmites/permits.php for details. Also, if you spray plants which are in the water or growing from ground which is below the "ordinary high water mark" (OHWM), do NOT use RoundUp or other products you buy off the garden store shelf, unless you can find a store which sells the herbicides and surfactants approved by the MDEQ for use to control aquatic plants. I have not found those products in local garden stores. One problem is that the products approved by the DEQ are usually only available as concentrates in minimum quantities of one gallon or many times two and a half gallons. However, there is one big advantage to mixing your own chemicals from concentrate. You can make it for a lot less than RoundUp. RoundUp costs about $12-14 per gallon. I mix up a similar product from concentrates for about $2 per gallon. It is a mix of Glyphosate (Aqua Star, AquaPro, GlyPro or Rodeo) and a surfactant (Cygnet Plus). Both are approved for spraying over and near water. These are of course alright for spraying over dry ground too. These products are available by mail order from a variety of chemical suppliers. See our webpage on Herbicides and Surfactants (http://www.stewartfarm.org/phragmites/herbicides.php) for details on these products and an explanation of surfactants.
Do I have to be certified to use Glophosate or to mix it with a surfactant?
From my discussions with The Michigan Department of Agriculture Pesticide and Plant Management Division individuals can purchase these products and mix and apply them themselves. Aqua Star is a registered pesticide in the State of Michigan and does not exclude use or mixing by noncertified individuals, nor does Cygnet Plus. People can mix these products themselves and they can apply them themselves if in compliance with the label requirements including the use of personal protective equipment and disposal. They can join with friends or neighbors to purchase, mix and apply these for each other as long as it is not for commercial purposes and not in the course of employment. When sharing with friends it might be a good idea to have mutual waivers to protect all parties involved from liability due to property damage or chemical exposure of any individual. Though the right to use these chemicals without a license applies to individuals and a group of friends it may not apply to organizations, such as a community group or homeowners association. Therefore, it appears to be better to informally share the cost and labor with friends rather than to create a formal group for this purpose.
If you choose to hire a company to do the treatments and they are going to spray near water, they should have a Pesticide Application Business License with a Category 5 (Aquatic Pest Management) classification and the person who does the work needs to be a Certified Commercial Pesticide Applicator whose certification includes Category 5. A list of Certified Commercial Pesticide Applicators is available online at http://www.mda.state.mi.us/pest/ You can also call the MDA at 517-373-1087 for assistance.
Whether you are spraying right from the bottle or mixing up the products yourself, follow all instructions on the labels, use proper procedures and all recommended safety equipment. See our webpage on Herbicide Safety and consider taking an herbicide safety class. See our other web page on the subject of herbicide safety at http://www.stewartfarm.org/phragmites/safety.php for details.
More details on when and how to treat the plants
In Southeast Michigan in general it is best to treat sometime between mid-August and the end of September, not before the seed head inflorescence is fully developed and not after the first killing frost or after the plant has started to go dormant for the winter (indicated by it starting to turn yellow). Michigan DNR feels that the later in the season that you treat it, the better. Phragmites can go dormant after many native plants. The perfect time to spray would be after natives are dormant, when the herbicide will not affect them. When weather has been appropriate some people have treated as late as mid-November if the Phragmites had not begun to move into dormancy.
Do not spray on a day when rain is expected. The longer the product stays on the plant the better.
If you are going to spray instead of dab it on, pick a day with little or no wind. Keep in mind that winds are generally less in the morning or late in the afternoon. Spray with the wind at your back to carry the chemicals away from you. In some cases you can use a breeze to carry the chemicals further into a dense stand of Phragmites. Be careful to avoid overspray from leaving the treatment area.
Spray while backing out of the area. You don't want to walk through an area just sprayed.
Most Phragmites control plans do not include removing the seed heads from the top of the plants. However, if you have a small stand of Phragmites and can physically remove the seed heads prior to treating, that would help reduce the seeds in the soil which might germinate someday. In Michigan, we are allowed to send highly invasive plants such as Phragmites to our land fills. If you remove the seed heads, put them in plastic garbage bags and put them out for your regular trash pick up. Make sure you do NOT put them in with other garden materials which might go to a compost facility.
Do not spray Phragmites which has been cut in the previous four weeks and do not cut the Phragmites during the two weeks following the treatment.
Choosing a Treatment or Application Method
The treatment method you use will depend on various factors.
What is the density of the stand of Phragmites?
What access do you have to the Phragmites?
Are the plants in water?
Are there other plants in the area which you want to protect?
How much do you have to spend?
How long can you wait to see it gone?
Do you feel comfortable with handling herbicides?
1 quart hand pump spray bottle
1 gallon hand pump spray bottle
2 or 3 gallon pump up sprayer
5 gallon pump up backpack sprayer
15 or 30 gallon sprayer mounted on an ATV or trailer
A sprayer on a boat
Aerial spraying from an airplane or helicopter
Cut and dab or inject
Dipped or sprayed cotton gloves over nitrile gloves for hand applying
Hire a certified pesticide applicator
Know Your Goals and Make a Plan
Do you want to restore a view of the water or provide access for recreational purposes? Are you concerned about fire safety for your home? In some cases regular cutting alone might serve those purposes. If the Phragmites is in the water, access for cutting may be difficult (except when the water is frozen) and herbicide treatment might be your only option, that is, if you can reach the Phragmites with the herbicide. If you are trying to bring back more native plants and animals, regular cutting would not be desirable and selective herbicide treatment with one winter cutting may be the best option. Decide whether you are trying to get rid of the Phragmites completely, remove some or just keep it from spreading? The best long range plan for many homeowners who want to get rid of as much of their Phragmites as possible would include a yearly cutting of the Phragmites in winter when the ground is frozen and yearly Glyphosate and surfactant treatment in September.
Results will not happen overnight. You should figure you will be working on it in the fall for several years in a row and that you will have to continue to spend a little time each year in general maintenance even after most of the Phragmites is gone. Photograph your progress to remind yourself how your work is paying off. Treat the outliers first then work on the main stands. Work with your neighbors if possible. Phragmites does not recognize property lines. You will have more work to control your Phragmites if you neighbors are not controlling theirs.
For the MDEQ webpage entitled "Control and Management of Invasive Phragmites"
If you would like to be on a general email list to receive notices of other phragmites control events and information about controlling phragmites send your name to Newsletter@phragmites.org along with a message which says "subscribe."
Bob Williams and Chuck Miller are forming a committee of Harsens
Islanders to continue to study the phragmites problem on Harsens Island and
its solutions. They welcome others who would like to join the effort by further
researching the topic and sharing knowledge on eliminating phragmites. If
you are interested contact Bob Williams at Bob@StewartFarm.org
or call Chuck Miller at 810-748-7209.